USMCA Trade Bill Addresses Trucking Competition

USMCA Trade Bill Addresses Trucking Competition

December 19, 2019  | Jeff Davis

This week, the House of Representatives passed the bill implementing the new U.S.-Mexico-Canada trade agreement (USMCA), which repeals and replaces the 1993 North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). The text of the implementing bill (H.R. 5430) is here and the full text of the USMCA agreement and all its annexes and side letters is here. The House passed the bill by a bipartisan vote of 385 to 41.

Subtitle C of title III of H.R. 5430 establishes a new process to deal with complaints that competition from Mexican trucking interests is hurting U.S. trucking interests. Any “interested party” (defined as a U.S. trucking company, trucking trade association, or labor union, or the Mexican government or Mexican citizens), or the President or the House Ways and Means Committee or Senate Finance Committee, can file a complaint with the new International Trade Commission, which shall then investigate to determine if Mexican competition “is causing or threatens to cause material harm to a United States long-haul trucking services industry.”

Within 120 days of commencing an investigation, the Commission shall make a determination, and if the determination is in the affirmative, the Commission shall “recommend the action that is necessary to address the material harm or threat of material harm found.” Eligible types of relief include the denial or revocation of U.S. trucking permits to Mexican trucking companies, or a cap on the total number of such permits.

The Commission would then submit a report to the President, who then shall order the Secretary of Transportation to provide the specified relief, and the Secretary shall carry out such relief – except that the President is not required to provide relief if he determines that relief is not in the national economic interest of the U.S. or would harm national security.

Section 327 of the bill also requires USDOT to carry out a survey of all existing permits given to Mexican trucking companies and all pending applications and report back to Congress and the Administration.

The Mexican truck issue has a long and torturous history. The 1993 NAFTA agreement required the U.S. to allow Mexican and Canadian trucking companies to operate throughout the U.S. (not just within the border zone within 25 miles of the border). The U.S. dragged its feet on implementing this provision, and Mexico filed a complaint with an international arbitration panel, which was decided in Mexico’s favor in February 2001. Congress then quickly enacted, in the fiscal 2002 DOT Appropriations Act, a series of requirements that had to be met before Mexican trucks were given access to the U.S. (see sec. 350 of P.L. 107-87).

Fulfilling those requirements took until February 2007, when the Bush Administration started a pilot program to allow Mexican trucks access to the U.S. on a trial basis. Congress then promptly de-funded this program (see sec. 136 of Division K of P.L. 110-161). After more objections, which went unheard by the U.S. government, Mexico issued retaliatory tariffs targeted at the states of prominent Members of Congress who opposed Mexican truck access – a 45 percent tariff on fresh grapes to mess with California, and Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-OR) claimed that tariffs of 20 percent on Christmas trees, pears, onions and cherries were targeting his part of Oregon.

President Obama then negotiated a new deal with Mexico on truck access, which was announced in March 2011 and which, when fully implemented, led Mexico to withdraw the retaliatory tariffs. A new pilot program was restored, and then, in 2015, FMCSA filed its formal report summarizing the results of the pilot program and announcing a permanent access program. The Teamsters and OOIDA filed a lawsuit to stop the program but their suit was bounced by the Ninth Circuit in June 2017.

Share

Related Articles

Federal Judge Finds Rhode Island's Truck Tolls on Interstate Bridges Unconstitutional

Federal Judge Finds Rhode Island's Truck Tolls on Interstate Bridges Unconstitutional

A federal judge this week ruled that Rhode Island's system of bridge tolls on heavy trucks is an unconstitutional restriction on interstate...

Senate Confirms Hutcheson to Head FMCSA

Senate Confirms Hutcheson to Head FMCSA

The U.S. Senate yesterday afternoon confirmed the nomination of Robin Hutcheson to be Administrator of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety...

Webinar: The Role of Technology in Modernizing Supply Chains

Webinar: The Role of Technology in Modernizing Supply Chains

The freight transportation sector has always been a leader in leveraging new technologies to improve operational speed, efficiency, and...

Gasoline Prices Rise Again, Diesel Supplies Tightening in Northeast

Gasoline Prices Rise Again, Diesel Supplies Tightening in Northeast

The House of Representatives is scheduled to vote next week on a bill making it a federal crime to sell gasoline at an "unconscionably...

Guest Op-Ed: Why Workforce Development Should Be Included in Freight Transportation Plans

Guest Op-Ed: Why Workforce Development Should Be Included in Freight Transportation Plans

Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, the United States’ supply chain system has been strained from significant demand. While some...

Webinar: The Emerging Future of Supply Chains

Webinar: The Emerging Future of Supply Chains

Many of the goods imported into the U.S. rely on intricate, finely-tuned, international supply chains. When the COVID-19 pandemic wreaked...

House Spins Wheels Reviewing Autonomous Vehicle Technology

House Spins Wheels Reviewing Autonomous Vehicle Technology

KITT, Herbie, the Batmobile – autonomous vehicles (AVs) have captured the public imagination for decades. Now, they’ve captured the...

Former NACTO President Hutcheson Replaces Joshi at FMCSA

Former NACTO President Hutcheson Replaces Joshi at FMCSA

With Meera Joshi headed to New York City to be a Deputy Mayor, it was announced this week that Robin Hutcheson will be replacing Joshi as...

White House Releases Plan to Address Truck Driver Shortage

White House Releases Plan to Address Truck Driver Shortage

This week, the White House released an "action plan" for the Biden Administration to address the oft-discussed truck driver shortage and...

“Where’s The Beef?” Supply Chain Issues Centennial Recap

“Where’s The Beef?” Supply Chain Issues Centennial Recap

Many of the goods imported into the U.S.—all told worth around $3 trillion—rely on intricate, finely-tuned international supply chains....

Guest Op-Ed: Rethinking the Truck Driver Shortage

Guest Op-Ed: Rethinking the Truck Driver Shortage

Many major media outlets such as CNN, The Wall Street Journal, and The New York Times recently reported that the nation's global supply...

White House Tries to Mediate Supply Chain Disruptions

White House Tries to Mediate Supply Chain Disruptions

Four months after creating a White House Task Force on Supply Chain Disruptions, and six weeks after appointing former Deputy U.S....

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks