Sidewalk Stakeholder Engagement and Underlying Equity Concerns

Sidewalk Stakeholder Engagement and Underlying Equity Concerns

February 22, 2019  | Alice Grossman

State DOTs, MPOs, and cities across the country have good examples of robust asset management systems and project prioritization methods for highways, local roads, transit projects, and freight projects, but examples of methodological pedestrian planning are rare. While pedestrian project stakeholder groups do not vary drastically across different communities, planning for equity in access, mobility, and safety will lead to different priorities depending on the jurisdiction. Pedestrian environments provide communities with an active transportation network that supports healthy lifestyles, fosters socio-economic growth, and facilitates access for disadvantaged groups.  As with other aspects of transportation systems, infrastructure availability and quality should meet the needs of communities and provide equitable access and mobility options. In order to do this, planners and decision-makers need the right tools to know the where existing infrastructure is and what the maintenance needs are, but also to understand who uses the sidewalks and what each stakeholders’ needs are.

In addition to higher rates of obesity, Americans walk less per day than people do in other nations, with an average step count in the U.S. of 5117 steps per day, and a large percentage of the population fits the common description of having a sedentary lifestyle.  Built environments that stimulate increased physical activity such as walking can help reduce chronic illnesses and premature death, support healthy aging, and improve mental health.  Creating walkable areas also has the potential to enliven business districts and reduce greenhouse gas emissions by encouraging modal shift from driving to walking for trips under a mile, thus lowering the number of vehicle trips.  Health problems associated with obesity, poor air quality, and related conditions are not equally spread across geodemographic groups, leading to inequities resulting in part from transportation infrastructure.

Many factors may be preventing members of various communities from using pedestrian infrastructure and walking as a form of transportation.  The availability of sidewalks and other pedestrian infrastructure, connectivity from origin to destination, sidewalk quality, safety concerns, and other factors may make it difficult or nearly impossible for people to walk from place to place.  A quarter of Americans report that they are discouraged from walking due to problems such as high vehicular speeds on adjacent roads or the absence of sidewalks.  These numbers increase in disadvantaged communities, where lack of transportation options and health problems are already a primary concern.  Persons with limited mobility are also significantly affected by sidewalks that do not meet standards set forth by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).  Proper infrastructure that enables pedestrian mobility is imperative for connecting people of all abilities to services.

Community stakeholders can become overwhelmed by a large backlog of sidewalk projects, especially given the common absence of a physical sidewalk inventory or asset management system.  Sidewalk planning is critical for improvements in public health, economic vitality, environmental quality, and for local fiscal responsibility, as evidenced by recent court rulings associated with ADA compliance, such as the $1.4 billion settlement the City of Los Angeles agreed to in 2015.  Given municipal fiscal constraints, implementation of improvements may also be constrained by indecision as to where to begin making improvements in the absence of a solid plan for project prioritization.  Furthermore, the public may consider allocations of funding for sidewalk repairs inequitable when undertaken in certain areas and not in others, or on a first-come, first-serve basis for people who file formal requests.  For this reason, agencies can become paralyzed, not wanting to implement sidewalk repairs until they have a complete inventory of sidewalk repair needs.

Equity in transportation planning has many definitions, but in general equity assessment examines the concept of ‘fairness’ in the allocation of goods and services and ties directly back to distributive justice.  In essence, equity assessment is concerned with who should benefit (and how much), who should pay (and how much), and why the distribution should be considered fair.  With respect to sidewalks, and the impact of sidewalk quality and availability on such transportation concepts as accessibility and mobility, the literature is fairly devoid of discussions on sidewalk equity.  Thus, little is currently known about the public’s perception of sidewalk costs and benefits.

Community leaders need information that is helpful for implementing overdue sidewalk network improvements in an equitable manner. For example, understanding how sidewalk repair and construction projects might be prioritized by gathering public input on project prioritization, funding mechanisms, and general perception of the local walking environment. However, public engagement can also lead to skewed input from the community.  There are inherent difficulties in holding in-person or virtual events that are accessible to and engage a representative sample of a community, as is also true with obtaining survey responses that mirror population demographic.  Inaction due to a lack of understanding of current conditions or will to address current and future needs hinders progress in designing and maintaining effective pedestrian-friendly environments.

This article was written based off of original research by and with support from David Boyer.

Share

Related Articles

FTA Opens Applications for Initial $343M Tranche of Transit Station Accessibility Grants

FTA Opens Applications for Initial $343M Tranche of Transit Station Accessibility Grants

Federal transportation officials this week announced the opening of an application round for a new federal grant program that will help...

The Journey to Making Transportation Available to Everyone

The Journey to Making Transportation Available to Everyone

When I think of an ideal future for transit, I envision a system that can and will be universally utilized by most, if not everyone, in...

Addressing Transportation Disparities by Embracing the Future of Mobility

Addressing Transportation Disparities by Embracing the Future of Mobility

The COVID-19 pandemic elevated our collective awareness of transportation disparities. Frontline workers have lower wages on average, are...

Community-Supported Plan Fuels Transportation Transformations

Community-Supported Plan Fuels Transportation Transformations

Sometimes neighborhood plans sit on the shelf—but sometimes they contain the right ingredients, bring together the right partners, and...

States 'Drive the Bus' for Rural, Small Urban, & Specialized Transit... Not Just Literally!

States 'Drive the Bus' for Rural, Small Urban, & Specialized Transit... Not Just Literally!

While they do not usually operate transit, state departments of transportation (DOTs) certainly “drive the bus,” metaphorically...

Toward a Multimodal California: How the State is Investing in Walking, Biking, and Transit

Toward a Multimodal California: How the State is Investing in Walking, Biking, and Transit

In the summer of 2011, I said goodbye to the 1997 Honda Accord I had driven since high school. Rather than upgrading to a newer vehicle,...

Webinar: Planning for People: The History and Future of Inclusive Transit Planning

Webinar: Planning for People: The History and Future of Inclusive Transit Planning

Who was transit built for? For what purpose? And how has that approach changed? Join Eno for a webinar that will answer these questions and...

Pivoting from Mobility on Demand to Food Delivery: Lessons from the MOD Pilot in Los Angeles

Pivoting from Mobility on Demand to Food Delivery: Lessons from the MOD Pilot in Los Angeles

The COVID-19 pandemic prompted transit agencies across the country to quickly modify service, protect the health of passengers and drivers,...

Webinar: What is next for MOD: Lessons from Los Angeles’ MOD Pilot During COVID

Webinar: What is next for MOD: Lessons from Los Angeles’ MOD Pilot During COVID

In January 2019, LA Metro launched a first-mile, last-mile mobility on demand (MOD) pilot with Via, offering shared rides to and from...

Guest Op-Ed: The Rise of Delivery as a Service

Guest Op-Ed: The Rise of Delivery as a Service

Everyday life entirely changed for most when the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 to be a global pandemic on March 11, 2020. Out...

Infrastructure measure includes fund to ensure nation’s transit stations are accessible

Infrastructure measure includes fund to ensure nation’s transit stations are accessible

Lawmakers have tucked a dozen or so similar funds into the package, according to an analysis by Jeff Davis, a senior fellow at the Eno...

Eno Releases New Mobility on Demand Reports with Data Insights and Recommendations

Eno Releases New Mobility on Demand Reports with Data Insights and Recommendations

Even before the COVID-19 pandemic, public transit in the United States was going through a very dynamic period. The FTA's MOD Sandbox...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks