Get On The Bus: Schools Should Work With the Transportation Sector For Better Student Transportation

Get On The Bus: Schools Should Work With the Transportation Sector For Better Student Transportation

December 01, 2017  | Ann Henebery

Earlier this month, voters in Dallas, Texas approved a ballot measure to dissolve the Dallas school bus system – Dallas County Schools (DCS). While the agency will be allowed to continue service for the remainder of the 2017 – 2018 school year, next year Dallas school districts will be on their own in providing transportation to their students. Districts are now deliberating whether or not they will manage school bus transportation themselves or if they will outsource the service.

The measure garnered a good amount of attention leading up to Election Day due to a number of controversies that have plagued the agency for years. DCS had previously been cited for reckless driving, running red lights, buses that were consistently late, and has struggled to pay off over $100 million in debt.

While DCS is an extreme example of the difficulties inherent in running a school transportation system, their struggles and ultimate dissolution provide a good opportunity to talk about the significant challenges that school transportation systems face all across the United States.

School transportation is the largest mass transit system in the United States (not to mention the safest) – transporting 25 million passengers in 500,000 buses every day. However, it is often an afterthought for local education leaders and it is almost never a part of the municipal or regional transportation system. In fact, in most regions across the United States, school transportation operates completely apart from the local transportation systems.

It also presents the education sector with a number of challenges:

Transporting students to and from school is expensive and becoming more so year by year. At the same time, dedicated funding for student transportation has stagnated. This means that school districts often find themselves dipping into funding meant for teachers, materials, or other resources.

School buses aren’t good for the environment. As of 2014, only about 6 percent of school buses purchased in the United States and Canada ran on alternative fuels. In contrast, 35 percent of public transit buses run on alternative fuels. Despite the fact that these fuels can actually add to the life of a vehicle, their higher up-front cost is enough to deter budget-conscious school districts from investing.

School transportation is complicated. When planning for and running school bus service for students, districts must remember a dizzying number of priorities, interests, and regulations. Safety, students with special needs, costs, environmental impact, and federal and state regulations make up a complex web of considerations that often limit how schools can design and fulfill service.

Districts often struggle with bus driver shortages as well. In a 2015 survey, 21 percent of school transportation contractors reported having a “severe” shortage of bus drivers. There are a number of reasons for this, but relatively low wages for drivers is an obvious barrier to retention. Higher salaries in other industries requiring the same qualifications (commercial drivers licenses, background check, CPR certification, drug testing, etc.) often draw bus drivers away from school transportation jobs. School bus drivers make on average $14.70 an hour. In comparison, public transit bus drivers make around $19.31 an hour.

Given these challenges, what can be done to improve school transportation?

New technology has helped many transportation companies and public agencies better monitor and manage their vehicle fleets. However, a survey from 2015 shows that only 33 percent of school buses use GPS (despite the fact that 72 percent of school bus operators purchased new buses). Even basic technologies like passenger counters are often absent from school buses. Schools should invest as much as they are able in technologies – i.e. WiFi and GPS – that can better help them better manage their systems, keep students safe, and gather data necessary for further improvements in the future.

That being said, while new technology would help many school districts, there is no doubt that modernizing bus fleets would be a strain on already tight school transportation budgets. In order to solve this dilemma, school districts should begin to work with their regional transportation systems (currently school boards comprise only 6.8 percent of MPO governing board members across the United States). This would allow schools to take advantage of planning expertise, new technologies, and, potentially, of funding programs available to the local metropolitan planning organization (MPO) and schools.

Transit systems already play a key role in many urban education systems. In fact, in Washington DC, unless a student with special needs qualifies for bus service, they must walk, bike, drive, or take transit to school. Dallas schools, as well as school districts across the country, would do well to seriously consider working more closely with transportation professionals in their regions. Doing so could greatly benefit not only students, but schools and communities as well.

Photos: Pixabay

Share

Related Articles

Webinar: Why Transit Agencies Need the Public to Take Ownership of the Transit Experience

Webinar: Why Transit Agencies Need the Public to Take Ownership of the Transit Experience

In this webinar, Saba Long and Alice Grossman will talk about why transportation organizations should invite the public to take an active...

Road to Recovery Webinar: The Federal Role in Transit's COVID Recovery

Road to Recovery Webinar: The Federal Role in Transit's COVID Recovery

Public transportation has been hit particularly hard by the COVID-19 pandemic. The stay at home orders have dramatically reduced ridership,...

DOT Announces $423M of Bus Grants to 94 Recipients in 42 States and DC

DOT Announces $423M of Bus Grants to 94 Recipients in 42 States and DC

The U.S. Department of Transportation today announced the recipients of $423.3 million in federal funding for bus and bus facility...

White House Endorses Ban on Chinese Bus and Rail Procurements

White House Endorses Ban on Chinese Bus and Rail Procurements

Yesterday, the White House issued an official endorsement of a version of language banning mass transit rolling stock procurements from...

House Climate Panel Debates Technology Investments in the Heavy-Duty Vehicle Sector

House Climate Panel Debates Technology Investments in the Heavy-Duty Vehicle Sector

July 19, 2019 On July 16,  the House Select Committee on the Climate Crisis held a hearing entitled “Solving the climate crisis:...

FTA Makes $85M in Low-No Emission Bus Grants

FTA Makes $85M in Low-No Emission Bus Grants

July 26, 2019 Earlier today, the Federal Transit Administration announced 38 grants to transit agencies for purchase of low or no emission...

The FY20 Budget: USDOT Competitive Grant Programs

The FY20 Budget: USDOT Competitive Grant Programs

March 20, 2019 What a difference a year makes. In its fiscal 2019 budget request, the Trump Administration requested zero dollars...

Key Senators Introduce Bill Banning Transit Agencies From Procuring Rolling Stock from China-Based Manufacturers

Key Senators Introduce Bill Banning Transit Agencies From Procuring Rolling Stock from China-Based Manufacturers

March 14, 2019 Today, a bipartisan group of Senators, including the chairman and ranking minority member of the committee with...

Op-Ed: Remembering George H.W. Bush and the ADA

Op-Ed: Remembering George H.W. Bush and the ADA

December 5, 2018 As the nation paused for the funeral of President George Herbert Walker Bush, his lasting mark on our transportation...

FTA Allocates Funding to L.A., Tempe, Minneapolis Transit Projects

FTA Allocates Funding to L.A., Tempe, Minneapolis Transit Projects

November 30, 2o18 This week, the Federal Transit Administration announced that they are formally allocating fiscal 2018 appropriations...

Is the Mass Transit CIG Program Sitting on $1.4 Billion? Or Is the Program $5 Billion in the Red?

Is the Mass Transit CIG Program Sitting on $1.4 Billion? Or Is the Program $5 Billion in the Red?

November 28, 2018 Is the Federal Transit Administration's Capital Investment Grant (CIG) program sitting on over a billion dollars of...

Voters Pass Six of 10 Biggest Transportation Ballot Measures

Voters Pass Six of 10 Biggest Transportation Ballot Measures

Updated December 3, 2018 With San Mateo County's Measure W squeaking by with a win, voters have now approved six of the 10 largest...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks