Scenario Planning for Automated Vehicles

Scenario Planning for Automated Vehicles

November 09, 2017  | Robert Puentes

In region after region, a growing chorus of leaders are calling for their city and metropolitan area to plan for a future of automated vehicles (AVs). Often these calls fall along a binary argument between what analysts call the “heaven’ and ‘hell’ scenarios (or ‘utopia’ or ‘dystopia’ visions) for AVs.

In the Heaven scenario, AVs a are parts of shared fleets of vehicles that travelers don’t own but use like we see today in some car and bike programs. There would be fewer parking lots and roadways since AVs use the infrastructure more efficiently and that land could be repurposed for other uses like recreation. Traffic congestion would be reduced and regional economies would prosper. In the Hell scenario, AVs would be individually owned, with private vehicles driving up vehicle miles travelled and emitting greater carbon emissions. Roadways would become parking lots as these private vehicles clog up streets and infrastructure would decline. Millions of jobs would be lost to automation.

While advocates on both sides like to set it all up as an either/or situation, the reality is that no one know for sure what the impact on AVs the built environment will be. Yet all over the country – and world – governments are under pressure to craft regulations to plan for a future that is difficult to forecast. Their predicament: how to develop ways to define how they grow, instead of being defined by it.

Fortunately, regions still have the ability to act proactively to craft the kind of future they want.

The approach comes from work pioneered in places like Minneapolis and San Diego a few years ago. The idea is to specifically connect metropolitan growth with transportation investments by examining land use patterns, density and urban form to find innovative solutions to challenges like housing, like carbon emissions, agricultural preservation, and economic development. These scenario planning tools enable practitioners to effectively plan for a range of changes and uncertainties through decision making processes that not only consider what is likely to happen but also, what communities want to happen in the future.

In Sacramento, for example, the region devised alternatives to current transportation investment priorities and land use patterns in order to get what it wanted: to increase travel options, shorten commutes, improve air quality, and provide for housing choices that more closely align with the needs of an aging population. This broad vision—the result of scenario planning with local officials and the general public—is intended to guide land-use and transportation choices over the next 50 years.

In Salt Lake City, Envision Utah is a public-private partnership that promotes sustainable growth in Utah’s Greater Wasatch Area through their Quality Growth Strategy. The strategy is a collection of six interconnected and intentional goals, including the promotion of transportation choices alongside the provision of housing choices at all income levels, and 32 strategies to meet these goals. One of the primary tools to inform those goals and strategies was the application of a scenario plan, which extrapolated past development trends to uncover what the region would look like if growth went unchecked.

New attention to these sophisticated tools is due to new provisions that are contained in 2012’s federal transportation law, the Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century (MAP-21). That law gave a big push for these tools in the move towards a more performance-based planning and the federal highway administration has just released a helpful guidebook to help regions understand how scenario planning can be a useful and effective tool in their transportation planning processes.

Regions should consider this guidebook and the new scenario planning practices as an indispensable tool as they wrestle with the uncertain future ushered in by AVs. Because while there is a lot we do not know, we do know regions cannot address tomorrow’s challenges with yesterday’s solutions. Now they have new tools.

Share

Related Articles

Guest Op-Ed: Transit Agencies Continue to Renew Their Missions and Reinvent Service

Guest Op-Ed: Transit Agencies Continue to Renew Their Missions and Reinvent Service

In 2020, all at once, public transportation providers were forced to confront multiple and varied challenges. Transit rose to the occasion...

Webinar: MOD Fare Integration for Transit

Webinar: MOD Fare Integration for Transit

This webinar is an overview of MOD Fare Integration for Transit: A Case Study in the Los Angeles and Puget Sound Regions, which is the...

Guest Op-Ed: The Role of Transportation in Improving America's Health

Guest Op-Ed: The Role of Transportation in Improving America's Health

The Eno Center for Transportation’s publication of my white paper, Increasing Access to Essential Health Functions: The Role of...

Op-Ed: From the Americans with Disabilities Act to Universal Design

Op-Ed: From the Americans with Disabilities Act to Universal Design

July 26, 2020 marked the 30th anniversary of the signing of The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990. Since then, huge strides...

The Role of Transportation in Improving America's Health

The Role of Transportation in Improving America's Health

Transportation access is one of the fundamental objectives of the public sector as a means to provide access to jobs, services, recreation,...

Webinar: The Role of Transportation in Improving America's Health

Webinar: The Role of Transportation in Improving America's Health

Transportation access is one of the fundamental objectives of the public sector as a means to provide access to jobs, services, recreation,...

Road to Recovery Webinar: Opportunities to Consider in Paratransit Operations

Road to Recovery Webinar: Opportunities to Consider in Paratransit Operations

In this webinar, join an interactive discussion about the opportunities, challenges, and lessons learned as transit agencies continue to...

Guest Op-Ed: Passengers with Disabilities and Workers Must Not Be Overlooked in COVID 4 Bill

Guest Op-Ed: Passengers with Disabilities and Workers Must Not Be Overlooked in COVID 4 Bill

Background As COVID-19 cases continue to rise in the U.S., the virus and our collective response is disproportionately affecting people...

Webinar: Urban Planning, Transportation, and Public Health Collaborations

Webinar: Urban Planning, Transportation, and Public Health Collaborations

This webinar will describe several ways in which urban planners are working with data sources and colleagues in public health and...

Happy Holidays with Mobility On Demand

Happy Holidays with Mobility On Demand

'Tis the season for sharing, and what better way to get into the spirit than with shared rides? Los Angeles County Metropolitan...

Roundtable Roundup: Adopting a Common Data Language to Enhance Mobility

Roundtable Roundup: Adopting a Common Data Language to Enhance Mobility

On Wednesday, November 20, 2019 AARP, the National Aging and Disability Transportation Center (NADTC), and the Transportation Research...

Webinar: Understanding How Women Travel

Webinar: Understanding How Women Travel

What are the needs and experiences of women traversing LA County? LA County Metro recently released a report, “Understanding How Women...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks