Q3 PTC Reports Show Some Railroads Still At Risk of Missing Deadline

Q3 PTC Reports Show Some Railroads Still At Risk of Missing Deadline

November 30, 2018  | Alexander Laska

November 29, 2018

According to railroads’ third-quarter 2018 reports released by the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA), four railroads are at risk of failing to qualify for an alternative schedule to finish implementing positive train control (PTC) by the Dec. 31, 2018 deadline.

To qualify for an extension of up to two years to finish implementing PTC, railroads must meet four criteria:

  1. At least 95 percent of all PTC system hardware installed
  2. Acquired all spectrum necessary for PTC, if applicable
  3. Initiated sufficient revenue service demonstration (RSD)
  4. Completed sufficient employee training

Based on that criteria, five railroads were still at risk of failing to qualify for an extension as of Sep. 30, 2018:

  • Amtrak is now no longer at risk, having risen from 92 percent of hardware installed at the end of the third quarter to 97 percent at the end of October (it had already met the other three criteria).
  • Caltrain now has 98 percent of hardware installed and has acquired all necessary spectrum, but has not initiated sufficient RSD or completed sufficient employee training.
  • New Jersey Transit only has 79 percent of its hardware installed but has met the other three criteria.
  • Altamont Corridor Express (ACEX) has only installed 70 percent of its hardware and has not initiated sufficient RSD, but has met the other two criteria. (ACEX tolda House subcommittee in September that the railroad was challenged by the small pool of vendors and that their status as one of the smallest railroads with PTC requirements put them “at the end of the line” to receive hardware.)
  • Capital Metropolitan Transportation Authority (CMTY) has only installed 85 percent of its hardware and has not initiated sufficient RSD, but has met the other two criteria.

In addition to those, Rio Metro has received an exemption until 2020, at which time they will need to be fully PTC compliant (in other words, no additional alternative schedule after that). As of Q3 2018, the railroad has made no reported progress toward implementation, though it did receive  the largest of the FY18 Positive Train Control Grants announced in August.

ACEX and CMTY both made significant installation progress over the past quarter—CMTY, for example, went from 19 percent of locomotive hardware installed to 63 percent—but it is unclear whether that trajectory will continue to allow them to qualify by year’s end.

Four railroads that were at-risk at the end of the second quarter are now on track to be eligible for an extension: Maryland Area Regional Commuter (MARC), Trinity Railway Express, South Florida Regional Transportation Authority, and Central Florida Rail Corridor (SunRail).

Of the 40 railroads with PTC requirements, the vast majority of them will need to apply for an extension, as they meet the aforementioned criteria but do not yet have all route miles in PTC operation. Most of them have not yet submitted their safety plans, which the FRA must review before approving the extension; the agency expects an influx of these at the end of December.

Even for those railroads that are further along, interoperability—different railroads’ PTC systems communicating with one another so that a train can move between different hosts’ infrastructure while remaining in PTC operation—will be an ongoing issue. This is particularly true for Class I railroads, nearly all of which have been conditionally certified but host several other railroads on their infrastructure, and Amtrak which operates on many different hosts’ tracks (in addition to the infrastructure it owns in the Northeast and Michigan). The interoperability challenge was a main focus at the recent House hearing on PTC.

Share

Related Articles

Op-Ed: Recognizing the Reasons for Railroad Deaths

Op-Ed: Recognizing the Reasons for Railroad Deaths

While we do not yet know the precise cause of the recent Amtrak derailment in Montana, the response was swift. The National Transportation...

Safer Railroading: A Guide Toward Targeted Safety Policy

Safer Railroading: A Guide Toward Targeted Safety Policy

Railroads are among the safest modes of transportation for workers, riders, and the public. Strong federal standards for railroad track and...

Webinar: Safer Railroading: A Discussion About Targeted Safety Policy

Webinar: Safer Railroading: A Discussion About Targeted Safety Policy

This webinar discusses the findings from Eno's report: Safer Railroading: A Guide Toward Targeted Safety Policy. According to Eno's...

A big bet on Amtrak

A big bet on Amtrak

That's "way more than any other" transportation secretary has ever been given, said Jeff Davis of the Eno Center for...

The infrastructure bill is more about maintaining train service than upgrading it

The infrastructure bill is more about maintaining train service than upgrading it

"Amtrak was set up to fail," Robert Puentes, CEO of the Eno Center for Transportation told CNN Business. "It wasn't designed to last as...

10 things to know about the infrastructure bill

10 things to know about the infrastructure bill

The bill would borrow some $118 billion from general revenue to meet the needs of the nation’s highways, bringing the grand total of...

Infrastructure bill may give Buttigieg final say over $105 billion

Infrastructure bill may give Buttigieg final say over $105 billion

But a tally by Jeff Davis of the Eno Center for Transportation, an independent charitable foundation, shows the DOT would be the big...

NEC Commission Announces $117 Billion Corridor Improvement Plan

NEC Commission Announces $117 Billion Corridor Improvement Plan

The Northeast Corridor Commission, a federal advisory panel for the DC-to-Boston passenger and commuter rail system, announced a new...

Amtrak pushes 15-year plan to boost northeastern corridor

Amtrak pushes 15-year plan to boost northeastern corridor

Jeff Davis, Senior Fellow of the Eno Center for Transportation, said he hopes that many of the Commission’s initial projects will be...

Amtrak is a top travel choice in the Northeast. With an ally in the White House, it wants trains in the rest of America.

Amtrak is a top travel choice in the Northeast. With an ally in the White House, it wants trains in the rest of America.

Robert Puentes, president and chief executive of the nonprofit Eno Center for Transportation, cautioned that not all of Amtrak’s proposed...

Next stop, Scranton? Biden's infrastructure plan could make it happen

Next stop, Scranton? Biden's infrastructure plan could make it happen

Paul Lewis, a vice president at the nonprofit ENO Center for Transportation in Washington, said bringing rail service to Scranton and...

Amtrak Route Expansion Largely Depends on State Willingness to Subsidize

Amtrak Route Expansion Largely Depends on State Willingness to Subsidize

Seeking to capitalize on President Biden's huge proposed spending increases as part of his American Jobs Plan, Amtrak last month released...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks