Point/Counterpoint: MPO Consolidation, Round 2

Point/Counterpoint: MPO Consolidation, Round 2

August 24, 2016  | Jeff Davis

This week, we have a second round of guest op-eds relating to the U.S. Department of Transportation’s proposed rulemaking that will have the effect of forcing the consolidation of many metropolitan planning organizations (MPOs) in metropolitan regions. (Eno’s Alex Bond explained the ramifications of the rule for subscribers in a July ETW article.)

Steve Heminger, who runs the large, integrated San Francisco Bay-area MPO (the MTC), argues that while MPO consolidation is often needed, the Department of Transportation would be better off using incentives rather than brute force to accomplish the goal. His op-ed is here.

And Carl Mikyska, who heads the Florida association of MPOs (MPOAC), argues that many MPOs are already cooperating quite well and agrees with Heminger that incentives are prefereable to force. His op-ed is here.

For an earlier set of op-eds exploring both sides of the topic, see this feature in our August 10, 2016 issue.

Interested in submitting an op-ed to ETW? Contact Alexander Laska at grogers[at]enotrans.org. 

Share

Related Articles

Peter DeFazio to Retire, Setting Off Race to Fill Head Dem Slot on T&I Panel

Peter DeFazio to Retire, Setting Off Race to Fill Head Dem Slot on T&I Panel

Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-OR), chairman of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, announced this week that he will not seek...

Senate Confirms Sullenberger to ICAO, Tees Up NMB Vote Next Week

Senate Confirms Sullenberger to ICAO, Tees Up NMB Vote Next Week

The U.S. Senate on December 2 confirmed former airline pilot Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger to be the U.S. Ambassador to the International...

Senate Panel Approves DOT, FMC Nominees, but Sen. Scott Puts Hold on All DOT Noms

Senate Panel Approves DOT, FMC Nominees, but Sen. Scott Puts Hold on All DOT Noms

On November 17, the Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee approved two more Presidential nominees for transportation...

White House Names 3 More DOT Nominees; 4 Others Approved in Committee

White House Names 3 More DOT Nominees; 4 Others Approved in Committee

This week, President Biden transmitted three more U.S. Department of Transportation nominees to the Senate, while the Commerce, Science and...

Guiding the New UAS Industry to Safety Excellence

Guiding the New UAS Industry to Safety Excellence

The aviation industry and regulators are achieving many notable successes in creating effective policies to facilitate the integration of...

Biden Signs Sweeping Market Competition/Concentration Order

Biden Signs Sweeping Market Competition/Concentration Order

On July 9, President Biden signed one of the widest-ranging executive orders of his Administration, EO 14036, "Promoting Competition in the...

Monje Confirmed at USDOT; White House Makes FMC Nomination

Monje Confirmed at USDOT; White House Makes FMC Nomination

Yesterday afternoon, the U.S. Senate confirmed the nomination of Carlos Monje, Jr. to be the number 3 official at the U.S. Department of...

Revised Version of House Democratic Transportation Bill to Be Marked Up Tomorrow

Revised Version of House Democratic Transportation Bill to Be Marked Up Tomorrow

Yesterday, the chairman of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee released a revised version of the INVEST in America Act...

Op-Ed: Federal Transportation Policy’s Prerequisites

Op-Ed: Federal Transportation Policy’s Prerequisites

The future of the federal surface transportation program is uncertain and clouded by an ever-widening range of parallel and perhaps...

Senate Likely to Amend Buy America Bill to Exempt Aggregates and Cement

Senate Likely to Amend Buy America Bill to Exempt Aggregates and Cement

After two weeks of floor debate and many amendments, the U.S. Senate is on the edge of passing S. 1260, a bill intended to revitalize U.S....

Pending Senate Bill Would Alter Buy America Requirements

Pending Senate Bill Would Alter Buy America Requirements

The U.S. Senate is in the middle of considering the "Endless Frontier Act" (S. 1260) – an umbrella bill assembled by Majority Leader...

House Members Request $20.8 Billion in Earmarks

House Members Request $20.8 Billion in Earmarks

Now that Congress has brought back earmarking, House members have filed requests for 5,267 projects totaling $20.75 billion. House...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks