Point/Counterpoint: DOT’s New MPO Consolidation Rule

Point/Counterpoint: DOT’s New MPO Consolidation Rule

August 10, 2016  | Jeff Davis

August 10, 2016

This week, we inaugurate a new recurring feature in ETW where we publish a matched set of op-eds giving the pros and cons of a particular issue.

On June 27, the U.S. Department of Transportation issued a surprise rulemaking that will have the effect of forcing the consolidation of many metropolitan planning organizations (MPOs) in metropolitan regions. Eno’s Alex Bond explained the ramifications of the rule last month in an ETW article.

This week, we have two perspectives on the proposed rule. First, we have Barry Seymour, the executive director of the Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission, who does not believe that forcing MPO consolidation would serve the public interest, particularly in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic areas. His op-ed is here.

We also have Eno’s Emil Frankel (writing in his individual capacity as a former state DOT commissioner and former U.S. Assistant Secretary of Transportation), who writes of his belief that many MPOs are too small and fragmented to serve the public good efficiently. His op-ed is here.

Interested in submitting an op-ed to ETW? Contact Alexander Laska at grogers[at]enotrans.org. 

Share

Related Articles

Mineta and Wachs: Two Giants Remembered

Mineta and Wachs: Two Giants Remembered

The transportation community lost two giants when Norm Mineta and Marty Wachs both passed away just over one year apart from one another....

Looking Beyond Infrastructure Week

Looking Beyond Infrastructure Week

Looking Beyond Infrastructure Week Infrastructure Week 2022 starts on Monday, May 16. After a decade of coordinated (and uncoordinated)...

Biden's Cure for High Gasoline Prices? The 2021 Infrastructure Bill

Biden's Cure for High Gasoline Prices? The 2021 Infrastructure Bill

"The Biden infrastructure law should produce reduced demand for gasoline once projects now being allocated funding [are]...

Workforce Issues Front-and-Center in Congress

Workforce Issues Front-and-Center in Congress

Last year, the President's National Infrastructure Advisory Council (NIAC) released a report concluding that the United States is...

White House Issues IIJA “Stewardship” Guidance

White House Issues IIJA “Stewardship” Guidance

The Biden Administration today issued a "stewardship" memo to all federal agencies regarding their implementation of the bipartisan...

Aviation Program Offset Blows Budget Hole in Senate’s COVID-19 Aid Plan

Aviation Program Offset Blows Budget Hole in Senate’s COVID-19 Aid Plan

The new CBO baseline will align with the Biden administration’s projection for the aviation program, said Jeff Davis, a senior...

Appeals Court Lifts Injunction, Allowing Interim Social Cost of Carbon Standard to Be Used in Rules, EIS

Appeals Court Lifts Injunction, Allowing Interim Social Cost of Carbon Standard to Be Used in Rules, EIS

On March 16, a federal appeals court removed an injunction that was blocking the ability of federal agencies, including the Department of...

House Members Review Current EV Development

House Members Review Current EV Development

It may seem a bit “shocking,” but the share of electric vehicles (EV) in the US is increasing. With more than 400,000 EVs in California...

Guest Op-Ed: The Real Danger of Mandatory Reciprocal Switching Is Freight Rail Stagnation

Guest Op-Ed: The Real Danger of Mandatory Reciprocal Switching Is Freight Rail Stagnation

On March 15, the Surface Transportation Board (STB) will hold a hearing on a 2016 regulatory proposal that would amend agency policy for...

A History of the Secretary's Ability to Approve (or Disapprove) Highway Projects

A History of the Secretary's Ability to Approve (or Disapprove) Highway Projects

The release of an unusual "policy statement" by the Federal Highway Administration in mid-December 2021 sparked a partisan row over whether...

Transportation and Infrastructure Mentions in the State of the Union Address, 2000-2021

Transportation and Infrastructure Mentions in the State of the Union Address, 2000-2021

As we all await President Biden's State of the Union address tonight, it is worth looking back at the times that recent Presidents have...

For Pete’s Sake! Sec. Buttigieg Won’t Push Back on States that Ignore Equity, Climate Guidelines

For Pete’s Sake! Sec. Buttigieg Won’t Push Back on States that Ignore Equity, Climate Guidelines

The Federal Highway Administration guidelines are, in fact, advisories that are not legally binding, as Jeff Davis of the Eno...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks