Op-Ed: Good Public Policy Drives Freight Rail Investment (Not Public Funding)

Op-Ed: Good Public Policy Drives Freight Rail Investment (Not Public Funding)

March 29, 2018  | Amy Hawkins

President Trump and many in Congress have placed a high priority on infrastructure investment.  The Administration’s plan has significant federal funding associated with it, primarily aimed at attracting more non-federal dollars into infrastructure, including private sector investment.  As Congress and the Administration consider this approach, it should be reassuring that substantial private investment is already being made to maintain and expand the nation’s freight rail network.  Freight railroads have invested around $26 billion a year over the last five years, and more than $635 billion since 1980, on capital expenditures and maintenance expenses related to locomotives, freight cars, tracks, bridges, tunnels and other infrastructure and equipment.  That’s more than 40 cents out of every revenue dollar plowed back into the rail network — about six times the rate of reinvestment of the average U.S. manufacturer.

To facilitate this investment, freight railroads require a growing economy and good public policy; federal policy makers (thankfully) don’t need to provide the funds that railroads spend.  But regulatory and other transportation policies have a large impact on freight rail investment, and the wrong policies can dampen what freight railroads spend. Therefore, it’s important to keep in mind how private sector rail investment is impacted by public policy, especially as infrastructure investment proposals progress through Congress.

First, pro-growth policies support freight rail investment; freight railroads invest to meet the growth in demand from customers. The recently passed tax reform bill is helping to drive growth which, in turn, should drive more railroad investment.  Good trade policy is also important to customer growth.  Almost 35% of freight rail revenues are derived from trade-related freight.

Turning to transportation policies, ongoing infusions of General Funds into federal highways subsidizes freight that goes over the highway.  Since “you get more of what you subsidize,” over time this will hurt freight railroad growth and related investment. Finding user-based revenue alternatives to the gas tax is a long-term goal whose time is coming, even if initially just for commercial users of the highways.

Finally, if federal regulatory policies reduce returns, strand capital or require inefficient operations, freight rail investment will be impacted. Safety regulations should encourage the use of new technologies and operating practices that provide for safe, and more efficient, operations.  And economic regulation must permit adequate returns to support investment.  Growth and improved freight rail earnings have allowed railroads to afford the massive spending necessary for maintaining infrastructure and equipment and provide the service customers require.

The supply chain is changing, driven by greater demands placed on transportation networks by e-commerce and changes in the industrial economy and energy markets.  But one thing is certain, the nation will need more private freight rail investment and productivity, not less. While Congress and the Administration grapple with the reality that the country’s publically-funded highways and bridges require more investment, they can take comfort in the fact that public policies supporting private investment in freight rail networks are relatively easier to achieve, and freight railroads are investing.

Want to stay in touch with Eno? Subscribe to our mailing list
Want to learn more about joining Eno?  Check out our individual and group memberships!

Share

Related Articles

Waterborne Competitiveness: U.S. and Foreign Investments in Inland Waterways

Waterborne Competitiveness: U.S. and Foreign Investments in Inland Waterways

Want a high level overview of this report? Sign up now for the webinar on June 7 with the authors. The 12,000-mile inland waterways...

House, Senate Advance WRDA Bills Authorizing $31B Texas Megaproject

House, Senate Advance WRDA Bills Authorizing $31B Texas Megaproject

This week, the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee approved bipartisan legislation reauthorizing the Army Corps of Engineers...

Webinar: Waterborne Competitiveness: Comparing U.S. and Foreign Inland Waterways

Webinar: Waterborne Competitiveness: Comparing U.S. and Foreign Inland Waterways

The 12,000-mile inland waterways network in the United States is a vital trade corridor serving energy, agriculture, and other freight...

Congress Kicks Off Full-Fledged Conference Committee on Economic Competitiveness Bill

Congress Kicks Off Full-Fledged Conference Committee on Economic Competitiveness Bill

The House and Senate kicked off the first formal intercameral conference committee of the current Congress, and the first one in several...

Surface Transportation Board Reauthorization Hearing Previews Future Rulings

Surface Transportation Board Reauthorization Hearing Previews Future Rulings

Exacerbated by supply chain bottlenecks and workforce woes, members of Congress expressed their concern with the recent performance of the...

Gasoline Prices Rise Again, Diesel Supplies Tightening in Northeast

Gasoline Prices Rise Again, Diesel Supplies Tightening in Northeast

The House of Representatives is scheduled to vote next week on a bill making it a federal crime to sell gasoline at an "unconscionably...

Guest Op-Ed: Why Workforce Development Should Be Included in Freight Transportation Plans

Guest Op-Ed: Why Workforce Development Should Be Included in Freight Transportation Plans

Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, the United States’ supply chain system has been strained from significant demand. While some...

Administration Again Proposes Unlikely Cuts in Corps Water Resources Budget

Administration Again Proposes Unlikely Cuts in Corps Water Resources Budget

The Biden Administration has proposed cutting the regular annual budget for the water resources program of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers...

Senate Passes Ocean Shipping Bill; Path to Reconciling With House Bill Unclear

Senate Passes Ocean Shipping Bill; Path to Reconciling With House Bill Unclear

Yesterday, the Senate passed legislation (S. 3580) reauthorizing the Federal Maritime Commission and making changes in ocean shipping law...

Guest Op-Ed: The Real Danger of Mandatory Reciprocal Switching Is Freight Rail Stagnation

Guest Op-Ed: The Real Danger of Mandatory Reciprocal Switching Is Freight Rail Stagnation

On March 15, the Surface Transportation Board (STB) will hold a hearing on a 2016 regulatory proposal that would amend agency policy for...

What's in the FY22 Omnibus: Water Resources Funding

What's in the FY22 Omnibus: Water Resources Funding

The just-passed fiscal year 2022 omnibus appropriations bill contains $8.3 billion in funding for the civil works (a.k.a. water resources)...

Links to the Text of Major Highway and Mass Transit Authorization Laws

Links to the Text of Major Highway and Mass Transit Authorization Laws

Links to the Text of Major Highway and Mass Transit Authorization Laws 2021 IIJA (Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act), a.k.a....

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks