MPO Planning Area Rule Reopens for Comments, Signaling a Softer Line on MPO Consolidation from USDOT

MPO Planning Area Rule Reopens for Comments, Signaling a Softer Line on MPO Consolidation from USDOT

October 06, 2016  | Alexander Bond

October 6, 2016

The FHWA/FTA proposed rule on Metropolitan Planning Organization Coordination and Planning Area Reform sparked quite a bit of interest on the pages of ETW (starting here) over the summer. The NPRM would essentially force over 140 MPOs to consolidate with nearby MPOs that serve the same Census-defined urban area. The NPRM generated 25 comments from the industry, associations, and the general public. Based on those comments and other feedback, FHWA and FTA have chosen to reopen the comment period. During this extended comment period, however, FHWA/FTA are principally interested in input on 3 specific questions: (a) under what circumstances would multiple MPOs be allowed to serve a single urban area; (b) the impact of requiring one set of plan documents; and (c) the forecasted cost of the proposed rule. Reopening of the comment period for these specific issues may foretell a softer line on the one-MPO-per-urban area standard that would spur mass consolidation.

Backing away from the one-MPO-per-urban area standard undercuts the primary argument for issuing this proposed rule in the first place. FHWA and FTA had stated that the proposed rule was a clarification of Congress’ intent in the 1991 ISTEA law. The administration cannot back away from this assertion, or the basis for issuing an administrative rulemaking also evaporates. The final rule will have to be carefully written to pass legal muster. As the Metropolitan Transportation Commission’s Executive Director Steve Heminger pointed out in his ETW guest column, the NPRM’s process for MPO boundary drawing treads perilously close to the line between the administrative rulemaking role of USDOT and the legislative role of Congress.

FHWA/FTA appear to have taken notice of the potential organizational and planning process issues associated with very large urban agglomerations being forced into a single MPO. In his guest column to ETW, Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission Executive Director Barry Seymour made this exact point. Although he expressed support for the spirit of the NPRM, former Connecticut Transportation Commissioner and Eno Senior Fellow Emil Frankel also agreed that certain megaregions—like the Northeast Corridor—would not be well served by being forced into a single MPO. Organizational process issues and costs featured prominently in many of the comments submitted during the first round, including in joint comments from all three MPO associations here.

If USDOT allows urban areas to be split into multiple MPOs, it would represent a major win for suburban local governments and the dozens of MPOs that were targeted for consolidation. Although some MPO realignment might still occur, the scope of the national MPO shuffle would be far less than what was envisioned in this summer’s NPRM.

Some version of the rule is still very likely to be finalized before the end of the Obama Administration. The reopened comment period closes on October 24th. People who responded during the original comment period do not need to resubmit comments unless they wish to add their opinion on the issues in question. Comments can be entered on the docket by following the instructions here.

Share

Related Articles

Congress’s Messy ‘Fix-It-First’ Fight Heats Up

Congress’s Messy ‘Fix-It-First’ Fight Heats Up

“Enactment of a CRA resolution doesn’t just overturn the rulemaking; it sows the earth with salt,” wrote Jeff Davis of Eno...

17 New Republicans Named to House T&I; Tom Cole to Chair THUD Appropriations

17 New Republicans Named to House T&I; Tom Cole to Chair THUD Appropriations

This week, a House Republican leadership panel named 17 new members to the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee (subject to...

Schumer Calls for Quick Confirmation of Phil Washington to FAA

Schumer Calls for Quick Confirmation of Phil Washington to FAA

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) issued a public statement on January 15 calling for the quick confirmation of Phil Washington,...

McCarthy (Finally) Makes Progress Towards Getting Speakership

McCarthy (Finally) Makes Progress Towards Getting Speakership

After a week of gridlock, House Republican Leader Kevin McCarthy (CA) finally made progress towards getting a majority of the House to back...

Biden Re-Nominates FAA, Amtrak, FMC Nominees

Biden Re-Nominates FAA, Amtrak, FMC Nominees

When the Senate adjourned sine die at the end of the 117th Congress, at 11:30 a.m. on January 3, all pending legislation died, and all...

Larsen to Take Lead Democratic Role on House T&I Panel

Larsen to Take Lead Democratic Role on House T&I Panel

Del. Eleanor Holmes Norton (D-DC) has announced that she was dropping her bid to replace the retiring Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-OR) as the lead...

Senate Confirms Primus to New STB Term, but Amtrak Nominees Will Wait Until Next Year

Senate Confirms Primus to New STB Term, but Amtrak Nominees Will Wait Until Next Year

As part of last night's 10 p.m. Senate "wrap-up" activities, the Senate confirmed, by unanimous consent, the nomination of Robert Primus to...

Democrats to Decide Ranking Slot on T&I Next Week After Larsen Wins Preliminary Endorsement

Democrats to Decide Ranking Slot on T&I Next Week After Larsen Wins Preliminary Endorsement

The House Democratic Caucus will vote next week whether to select Del. Eleanor Holmes Norton (D-DC) or Rep. Rick Larsen (D-WA) as ranking...

GAO Sets Up Likely Veto Showdown Between Congress and Biden Next Year Over Pollack Memo

GAO Sets Up Likely Veto Showdown Between Congress and Biden Next Year Over Pollack Memo

Today, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) issued a six-page ruling determining that the December 2021 "Pollack memo" urging Federal...

Senate Confirms Bhatt to Run FHWA; Amtrak Nominees Expected to Wait in Limbo

Senate Confirms Bhatt to Run FHWA; Amtrak Nominees Expected to Wait in Limbo

The U.S. Senate on December 8 confirmed Shailen Bhatt to be Administrator of the Federal Highway Administration, by voice vote. Bhatt...

Inflation Is Cutting into States’ Big Infrastructure Windfall

Inflation Is Cutting into States’ Big Infrastructure Windfall

“It’s still eating away slowly but surely,” said Jeff Davis, a senior fellow at the Eno Center for Transportation, a Washington,...

Senate Committee Hears Private Sector on IIJA Implementation

Senate Committee Hears Private Sector on IIJA Implementation

On Wednesday, November 30 at 10 a.m., building on the work of its IIJA public sector implementation subcommittee hearing two weeks ago, the...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks