Mass Transit: Budget Leaves No Room for New New Starts

Mass Transit: Budget Leaves No Room for New New Starts

May 25, 2017  | Jeff Davis

May 25, 2017

The 2018 budget requests $11.226 billion in total resources for the Federal Transit Administration (FTA). The full $9.733 billion in spending from the Highway Trust Fund for formula grants is requested. But where general fund spending for transit is concerned, the request for FTA Capital Investment Grants is cut almost in half from the level authorized in the FAST Act – from $2.3 billion to $1.2 billion.

The budget requests the full 2018 installment payment projects of all 12 CIG projects that currently have full funding grant agreements (FFGAs) that have been signed and executed by FTA. These total $1.108 billion. In addition, Transportation Secretary Chao told Senator Dianne Feinstein (D-CA) over the weekend that she would sign the pending FFGA for Caltrain electrification, which will take another $100 million in 2018, bringing the committed total to $1.208 billion.

Take away 1 percent of the appropriation for oversight activities per the statute, and that only leaves $11.8 million in the account at the requested level. This is not enough for the estimated 2018 payments for any of the five projects that are currently in the New Starts Engineering phase and expect to get their FFGAs executed in 2017 or 2018 (Santa Ana streetcars, Maryland Purple Line, Minneapolis Blue Line LRT extension, Minneapolis Southwest LRT, and Seattle Lynwood Link).

In the 2018 New Starts Annual Report issued this week, the FTA states “When preparing funding recommendations for the upcoming fiscal year, FTA honors the commitments made in existing construction grant agreements. New projects not yet under construction grant agreements are recommended for funding only if proposed CIG funding levels are sufficient.”

Therefore, the Administration is using its own budget proposal and its lack of money in 2018 and beyond to justify its refusal to sign the FFGAs for the Purple Line and the other projects under New Starts Engineering, which would require an additional $3.4 billion in federal appropriations in 2018 and future years if their FFGAs get executed.

The Purple Line and Seattle-Lynwood have already received significant appropriations from Congress in advance of FFGA execution, because Senators Barbara Mikulski (D-MD) and Patty Murray (D-WA) were (and in the latter case still are) extremely senior and powerful members of the Senate Appropriations Committee. But attempts by Congress to force the Trump Administration to sign particular FFGAs and release previously appropriated funds, or commit future appropriations, are on uncertain legal ground.

The House and Senate Parliamentarians have been interpreting the self-imposed “earmark” bans in both chambers as exempting projects requested in the President’s budget. Congress can deny funding for projects that were in the budget request, and can increase or reduce funding for projects requested by the President, but it cannot fund new projects that were not in the budget request without violating the earmark ban.

Therefore, it does not appear that Congress can provide funding in the 2018 appropriations process for projects that were not requested for funding in the 2018 New Starts Report without violating the earmark ban (unless Congress gets rid of the earmark ban, as many members from both parties wish, many secretly).

Getting DOT to release the appropriations made in previous years for certain CIG projects, or forcing DOT to release future appropriations, is also legally problematic. The statute (49 U.S.C. §5309) says that the Secretary “may” enter into FFGAs under certain conditions, not “shall” enter into them. And while the Impoundment Control Act normally requires the executive branch to make appropriations available for obligation for the purposes appropriated, subject to delays that are limited by statute, this is complicated for these particular projects for two reasons:

  1. The appropriations laws for the last few years do not mention specific projects – only the conference statement of managers or other explanatory statements list specific projects and dollar amounts for them. Such extralegal report language is not necessarily legally binding on agencies. It’s a gray area.
  2. Appropriations for the CIG account are “no-year” funding, i.e. “available until expended,” so there is no actual deadline for the executive branch to put the funds out there before forfeiting them, complicating the Impoundment Control Act calculus.

In the rest of the mass transit budget, funding for FTA overhead is requested at $110.8 million, between the enacted 2016 and 2017 levels, and grants to WMATA get a pro forma cut from $150.0 million to $149.7 million in the request because FTA was freezing at the “haircut” rate in the FY17 CR. (FY 2018 is year 9 of the 10-year $1.5 billion WMATA authorization under the 2008 PRIIA law).

The budget does not request any money for FTA research or training programs from the general fund, which got a $5 million appropriation in 2017.

Share

Related Articles

Senate Fails to Advance Bill Containing Extra $2B for Intercity Bus COVID Relief

Senate Fails to Advance Bill Containing Extra $2B for Intercity Bus COVID Relief

The U.S. Senate earlier today failed to muster the 60 votes necessary to bring up a $48 billion bill providing additional COVID relief,...

Buttigieg Defends FY23 Budget Request before Senate Appropriations

Buttigieg Defends FY23 Budget Request before Senate Appropriations

Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg appeared before the Senate Appropriations Committee yesterday to defend the Biden Administration's...

Congressional Leaders Open Negotiations on FY23 Spending Total

Congressional Leaders Open Negotiations on FY23 Spending Total

The leaders of the House and Senate Appropriations Committees met yesterday to begin discussions of an overall total for the twelve regular...

USDOT Gets FY22 Highway and Transit Formula Funding Increases Out the Door

USDOT Gets FY22 Highway and Transit Formula Funding Increases Out the Door

Twin announcements from the U.S. Department of Transportation in the last week have given state and local governments permission to spend...

Step-by-Step: How $52.5 Billion in New Highway Formula Funding Becomes $47.1 Billion

Step-by-Step: How $52.5 Billion in New Highway Formula Funding Becomes $47.1 Billion

When Congress passed the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act last year, that bipartisan law was built around significant increases in...

Administration Again Proposes Unlikely Cuts in Corps Water Resources Budget

Administration Again Proposes Unlikely Cuts in Corps Water Resources Budget

The Biden Administration has proposed cutting the regular annual budget for the water resources program of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers...

Budget Proposes 14% Non-Defense, 4% Defense Discretionary Appropriations Increases

Budget Proposes 14% Non-Defense, 4% Defense Discretionary Appropriations Increases

President Biden's fiscal 2023 budget request went to press before the Office of Management and Budget was finished tallying up the fiscal...

$2.85 Billion Request for CIG in FY23; Allocation Strategy for IIJA Funding Revealed

$2.85 Billion Request for CIG in FY23; Allocation Strategy for IIJA Funding Revealed

President Biden's fiscal 2023 budget request, released yesterday, includes a $2.85 billion request for appropriations for the Federal...

FY22 Omnibus Appropriations: The Final Tally

FY22 Omnibus Appropriations: The Final Tally

On Monday, March 14, four days after Congress had passed the omnibus appropriations bill for fiscal 2022 and sent it to the President, the...

What's in the FY22 Omnibus: US Department of Transportation

What's in the FY22 Omnibus: US Department of Transportation

Following is a summary of the USDOT funding in the omnibus appropriations bills. Readers are also encouraged to download this PDF...

What's in the FY22 Omnibus: Water Resources Funding

What's in the FY22 Omnibus: Water Resources Funding

The just-passed fiscal year 2022 omnibus appropriations bill contains $8.3 billion in funding for the civil works (a.k.a. water resources)...

What's in the FY22 Omnibus: The Big Picture

What's in the FY22 Omnibus: The Big Picture

Eleven months passed between the release of President Biden's fiscal 2022 discretionary appropriations proposal on April 9, 2021 and the...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks