House Votes to Reject Carbon Tax as Curbelo Prepares to Introduce HTF Carbon Tax Bill

House Votes to Reject Carbon Tax as Curbelo Prepares to Introduce HTF Carbon Tax Bill

July 20, 2018  | Jeff Davis

July 20, 2018

The House of Representatives this week passed a non-binding resolution rejecting the idea of a carbon tax as bad for the economy as one Republican prepares to introduce a bill next week replacing the federal motor fuels tax with a carbon tax.

Yesterday, the House voted, 229 to 180 (roll call here), to pass H. Con. Res. 119, which expresses the sense of Congress that a carbon tax “would be detrimental to American families and businesses, and is not in the best interest of the United States.” The vote was predominantly party-line, with only six Republican “no” votes and only seven Democratic “yes” votes.

Yes No “Present”
Republicans 222 6 1
Democrats 7 174 1
TOTAL 229 180 2

Meanwhile, Rep. Carlos Curbelo (R-FL) is preparing to introduce legislation in the House next week levying a new carbon tax on CO2 emissions and using it to replace the existing federal taxes on gasoline, diesel fuel, and kerosene. In a draft summary of the legislation, the tax rate would be set at $23 per metric ton of CO2 emissions to start with, plus annual increases of two percent per year, plus a CPI inflation adjustment.

From a transportation perspective, the important thing to remember is that the burning of fossil fuels by the transportation sector only accounts for 36 percent of total CO2 emissions from fossil fuel combustion in the United States, according to the latest EPA estimates (see table ES-3 here).

Yet, under the draft Curbelo plan, the transportation sector would get 72.5 percent of the proceeds of the carbon tax (70 percent to the Highway Trust Fund and 2.5 percent to the Airport and Airway Trust Fund). 10 percent would go to states for grants to low-income households (a souped-up LIHEAP), 5 percent would go towards grants to states for coastal infrastructure resiliency, 3 percent to displaced energy workers, 2.5 percent for agricultural environmental incentive grants, 2 percent for coal mine cleanup, and the rest for a variety of research and mitigation programs. (This could all change by the time the final bill is introduced next week, of course.)

In 2016, fossil fuel combustion accounted for almost 5 billion metric tons of CO2 release in the United States. Exemptions and credits in the draft bill summary make it impossible to score. However, the Curbelo bill would tax CO2 release at $23 per ton to begin with. Even when the credits and the exemptions for de minimis producers and sectors are included, the legislation has the potential to deposit revenues into the Highway Trust Fund far in excess of the $35 billion per year that is currently deposited from the existing excise taxes on gasoline and diesel fuel.

Of course, giving the Highway Trust Fund the proceeds of wide-ranging taxes on non-transportation users instead of a dedicated tax on the highway use of motor fuels would put the final nail in the coffin of the user-pay, user-benefit principle that is supposed to underlie all federal trust funds. (The concept has taken a beating with the bailouts from general revenues supplementing the Trust Fund since 2008, but the Curbelo bill would make it official and permanent.)

Share

Related Articles

EPW Panel Releases Revised Text of Its Budget Reconciliation Title

EPW Panel Releases Revised Text of Its Budget Reconciliation Title

The Senate Environment and Public Works Committee today released its title of the "Build Back Better" budget reconciliation bill today, the...

White House, Congress Push Plans for Reducing Emissions from Aviation

White House, Congress Push Plans for Reducing Emissions from Aviation

The Biden Administration yesterday announced a new initiative to develop sustainable aviation fuels. In an extensive fact sheet released by...

Federal program to cut bus emissions gets a Senate mandate: Some buses must pollute

Federal program to cut bus emissions gets a Senate mandate: Some buses must pollute

Still, the five-year total of nearly $107 billion for transit was about 65% above what was expected if spending remained flat in that...

Biden Issues Executive Order Advancing Clean Car Goals

Biden Issues Executive Order Advancing Clean Car Goals

Last Thursday, August 5, the Biden administration issued an executive order with new rules aimed at reducing automobile emissions. The new...

Op-Ed: Bipartisan Infrastructure Bill Could Be a Win for Climate, If it Can Be Leveraged to Those Ends

Op-Ed: Bipartisan Infrastructure Bill Could Be a Win for Climate, If it Can Be Leveraged to Those Ends

The newest assessment report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, released this week, was depressing. Not that it contained...

Critics: 'big and bold' infrastructure bill falls short on helping states fight climate change

Critics: 'big and bold' infrastructure bill falls short on helping states fight climate change

It also includes $107 billion for transit, a 65% boost, according to an analysis by Jeff Davis, a senior fellow at the nonpartisan Eno...

Where does the infrastructure compromise deal leave EV charging?

Where does the infrastructure compromise deal leave EV charging?

“If a reconciliation bill emerges with 10 digits of guaranteed EV rebate money, that will go a long way towards reassuring...

Infrastructure bill's climate-change features face tricky path over money for electric cars

Infrastructure bill's climate-change features face tricky path over money for electric cars

“If a reconciliation bill emerges with 10 digits of guaranteed EV rebate money, that will go a long way towards reassuring automakers...

Climate crisis turns world's subways into flood zones

Climate crisis turns world's subways into flood zones

Retrofitting subways against flooding is “an enormous undertaking,” said Robert Puentes, chief executive of the Eno Center for...

A symbol of freedom or a 4,000 pound tool of destruction? The car’s legacy faces a reckoning

A symbol of freedom or a 4,000 pound tool of destruction? The car’s legacy faces a reckoning

Analysis: Electric bus maker BYD shows China complications in Biden climate push

Analysis: Electric bus maker BYD shows China complications in Biden climate push

"It's very difficult with the current manufacturing infrastructure in this country and with BYD out of the process, to imagine getting this...

House Climate Crisis Select Committee Considers Transportation Priorities

House Climate Crisis Select Committee Considers Transportation Priorities

On June 30, the House Select Committee on the Climate Crisis held a hearing, “Transportation Investments for Solving the Climate...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks