House Spending Bills Freeze FY21 Water Infrastructure Funding at FY20 Levels

House Spending Bills Freeze FY21 Water Infrastructure Funding at FY20 Levels

July 07, 2020  | Jeff Davis

The House Appropriations Committee has been releasing the text of draft appropriations bills for fiscal year 2021 every two hours this week, and the bills that fund the Army Corps of Engineers water resources program and the Environmental Protection Agency’s water infrastructure grant programs were released yesterday. (7/9/2020 addendum: The draft bill was approved in subcommittee by voice vote later on July 7 and is scheduled to be considered by the full Appropriations Committee at 1 p.m. on Monday, July 13.)

Both bills largely freeze water infrastructure funding for 2021 in the regular budget at around the enacted fiscal year 2020 levels (while rejecting large cuts proposed by the Trump Administration). But they also include much more money in the back of each bill designated as an off-budget emergency, subject to a type of line-item-veto by the President.

This is largely a consequence of the two-year discretionary spending totals for the fiscal 2020-2021 biennium enacted in the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2019. Under that law, the ceiling on total non-defense discretionary appropriations (excluding the ever-growing list of cap work-arounds) rose by $19.5 billion in 2020 (versus the FY 2019 cap), to $666.5 billion, but the cap only increases by an additional $5 billion in 2021, to $671.5 billion. And it appears that the lucky programs that will get some of that $5 billion non-defense increase will not include water infrastructure programs.

Corps of Engineers. The draft Energy and Water Development appropriations bill for 2021 provides a total of $7.63 billion in appropriations for the Corps’ “civil works” program in 2021, which is an ever-so-slight $21.1 million decrease from the 2020 enacted level. This is, however, a $1.66 billion increase over the Trump Administration’s request, and it is that increase above the request that the press release brags about.

Funding for Investigations (the project studies that might, some day, grow up to be new construction projects) is frozen at last year’s $151 million, with the bill directing the Corps to use some of that money to start seven new project studies during 2021. The Construction account sees a $61 million reduction from last year and the Operations and Maintenance account gets a $48 million increase over last year.

The Administration proposed to shift the cost burden of cleaning up old Energy Department nuclear weapons reactors from the Corps budget to the Energy Department budget, but the House bill keeps it within the Corps and gives it a $10 million increase over last year.

The committee says that the total amount of funding provided from the Harbor Maintenance Trust Fund under all of the projects to be funded by the bill will be $1.68 billion.

As is the case with other House bills for FY21, the spending increases that are not possible under the budget caps are provided separately via off-budget emergency appropriations, which face a much more difficult path to enactment. The $43.5 billion in emergency appropriations are in title VI of the bill while the regular annual bill is titles I-V. For the Corps, this is essentially a “shadow budget” that dwarfs the regular Corps budget:

Regular Emergency
(Subject to (Exempt
BCA Caps) from Caps)
Investigations 151 110
Construction 2,620 10,000
Mississippi River System 365 875
Operation and Maintenance 3,838 5,000
Regulatory Program 205 50
Former Nuclear Sites Cleanup 210 500
Flood Control / Coastal Emergencies 35 415
Expenses 200 50
Office of the Asst. Secretary 5 0
Total, Corps of Engineers (Civil) 7,629 17,000

However, if the draft bill was presented to the President tomorrow (unchanged), he could sign it and approve the $49.6 billion in regular funding and at the same time he could effectively veto all $43.5 billion of the emergency funding. You might ask, how could he do that since a line-item veto is unconstitutional?

The answer lies in the back of the bill:

Sec. 607. Each amount designated in this Act by the Congress as being for an emergency requirement pursuant to section 251(b)(2)(A)(i) of the Balanced Budget and Emergency Deficit Control Act of 1985 shall be available (or rescinded or transferred, if applicable) only if the President subsequently so designates all such amounts and transmits such designations to the Congress.

“Shall be available” is budget-speak for “can be obligated and spent” – so all the emergency money in the bill can only be obligated in spent if the President signs a piece of paper like this one and sends it to Congress after he signs the bill into law. (See George W. Bush’s refusal to approve $5.1 billion in such “contingent emergencies” in a bill he signed in August 2002 – page 1387, here.)

EPA water infrastructure programs. The draft Interior and Environment appropriations bill for 2021 freezes funding for grants to states to capitalize state revolving funds (SRFs) at the fiscal 2020 enacted levels. Those are $1.639 billion for Clean Water Act SRFs and $1.126 billion for Safe Drinking Water Act SRFs. These levels are, however, $782 million above those requested by the Trump Administration for 2021, so it is the requested levels cited in the press release, not the 2020 levels.

Funding for the cleanup of abandoned service stations gets $92.5 million in the House bill out of the Leaking Underground Storage Tank (LUST) Trust Fund, about $600 million above the 2020 level. With that funding level, the LUST Trust Fund should have at least $800 million left at the end of 2021 (even if FY 2020 and 2021 gas and diesel tax receipts drop by a full 40 percent each year because of COVID-19). The LUST Trust Fund is a popular target for Congress when it wants to take money from elsewhere to plus up the Highway Trust Fund, and LUST won’t miss $800 million.

The situation regarding the EPA’s WIFIA loan and loan guarantee program is odd. The fiscal 2020 appropriations act directed EPA, OMB and Treasury to “jointly develop criteria for project eligibility for direct loans and loan guarantees authorized by the [WIFIA statute] that limit Federal participation in a project consistent with the requirements for the budgetary treatment provided for in section 504 of the Federal Credit Reform Act of 1990 and based on the recommendations contained in the 1967 Report of the President’s Commission on Budget Concepts…” The agencies were directed to print those standards in the Federal Register within 120 days of the enactment of the law, so that deadline was April 18, 2020.

The agencies did not publish the standards in the Register until last week (June 30) – more than two months after the deadline.

The Administration requested $25 million for the program in 2021 – $5 million for administrative expenses, and $20 million for the subsidy cost of low-interest loans. The House bill provides zero new funding – but the program had $116 million in unobligated balances at the start of fiscal 2020, plus the $60 million in new appropriations made for FY 2020 ($55 million for subsidy money and $5 million for admin). The House bill, on page 95, rescinds “All unobligated balances from amounts appropriated in fiscal years preceding fiscal year 2020…for the cost of direct and guaranteed loans.”

Then, on page 88 of the bill, it appropriates “an amount equal to the amount rescinded” as new funding for fiscal 2021 – but it also provides that none of the fiscal 2021 appropriations (which are all the pre-FY20 appropriations) shall be available for any loan or loan guarantee unless EPA and OMB certify in advance that the loan or guarantee complies with the new eligibility criteria from the June 30 Federal Register notice.

Unusually, the bill also reveals some behind-the-scenes drama – the bill orders EPA to “promptly provide” information on WIFIA applications to the Congressional Budget Office, if requested. This has to mean that EPA was refusing to share information with CBO in a timely manner, which was, in turn, preventing CBO from being able to score the spending rate of the program accurately.

The bill only provides an appropriation of $1 million for WIFIA administrative expenses, not the $5 million per year it has been receiving and which was requested.

Put all that together and this certainly looks like a smackdown by the appropriators of whoever has been running the WIFIA program at EPA.

As with the Energy and Water bill, the Interior/Environment bill contains an extra title at the back with a bunch of emergency appropriations for infrastructure programs that, in this case, dwarfs the amount of money provided by the regular budget. However, the money only can come into existence if the President signs that emergency designation piece of paper after he signs the bill. In millions of dollars:

Regular Emergency
(Subject to (Exempt
BCA Caps) from Caps)
Clean Water SRF Grants 1,639 6,355
Safe Drinking Water SRF Grants 1,126 3,855
Share

Related Articles

House Starts FY22 Appropriations Process, Deeming 9.5 Percent Funding Increase

House Starts FY22 Appropriations Process, Deeming 9.5 Percent Funding Increase

The annual appropriations process for fiscal 2022 will start next week, now that the House Appropriations Committee has been given a $1.5...

Next Steps on Appropriations: House to

Next Steps on Appropriations: House to "Deem" Massive Domestic Spending Increase, Consider $84.3B THUD Request

Now that President Biden has submitted his full budget request for fiscal year 2022, Congress can get to work considering the request....

FY22 Earmarking Structure Takes Shape

FY22 Earmarking Structure Takes Shape

Plans for Congress to bring back earmarked transportation projects this year are proceeding apace in three of the four power structures...

Buttigieg Defends His First Budget Before House Appropriations

Buttigieg Defends His First Budget Before House Appropriations

U.S. Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg went before the House Appropriations Committee this week to defend part of the Biden...

First Biden Budget Prioritizes Education, Health, Environment, Research

First Biden Budget Prioritizes Education, Health, Environment, Research

The White House released President Biden's discretionary spending summary today as the initial part of his fiscal 2022 budget request to...

FY22 Discretionary Funding Request Would Boost Amtrak, New Starts

FY22 Discretionary Funding Request Would Boost Amtrak, New Starts

Today, the White House sent Congress the first parts of its fiscal 2022 budget request – the overall parameters (rounded to the hundred...

Reconciliation Bill On Hold Pending Unemployment Insurance Agreement

Reconciliation Bill On Hold Pending Unemployment Insurance Agreement

The only thing more tedious than a Senate vote-a-rama is, apparently, a suspended vote-a-rama. The period of post-debate amendment...

House Democrats Bring Back Appropriations Earmarks, but Transportation Scope Unclear

House Democrats Bring Back Appropriations Earmarks, but Transportation Scope Unclear

The new chairman of the House Appropriations Committee announced on February 26 (in a 5 p.m. Friday afternoon news dump) that the committee...

Final FY21 Appropriations Bill Gives $88 Billion to USDOT

Final FY21 Appropriations Bill Gives $88 Billion to USDOT

Division L of the massive 5,600-page year-end funding bill is the regular Transportation-HUD appropriations bill for fiscal year 2021, and...

House Passes WRDA Compromise, but Bill Looks Dead in Senate

House Passes WRDA Compromise, but Bill Looks Dead in Senate

The House of Representatives passed a compromise biennial authorization bill for the Army Corps of Engineers water resources program this...

WRDA Bill (Now With Stimulus!), One-Week CR On House Floor This Week

WRDA Bill (Now With Stimulus!), One-Week CR On House Floor This Week

Congress is expected to pass a one-week extension of federal appropriations this week, from the current expiration date of Friday, December...

Bipartisan Offer May Be the Needed Breakthrough on COVID Relief Talks

Bipartisan Offer May Be the Needed Breakthrough on COVID Relief Talks

After the collapse of the daily COVID relief talks between House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin a few...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks