Guest Op-Ed: Congress Did Not Intend Greenhouse Gases to Be Measured for Highway Performance

Guest Op-Ed: Congress Did Not Intend Greenhouse Gases to Be Measured for Highway Performance

August 18, 2016  | Jim Inhofe

Guest op-ed by Senator James M. Inhofe (R-OK), chairman, Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works

August 18, 2016

My committee, the U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, not only writes and enacts laws to provide direction for programs within our jurisdiction; it is also our job to oversee implementation of laws by federal agencies.. Currently two laws are undergoing this process: the Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century (MAP-21) Act (P.L. 112-141), enacted with strong bipartisan support in 2012, as well as the more recent Fixing American’s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act (P.L. 114-94), enacted last December.

As the lead Republican author of these two laws, I am proud of the legislative reforms we accomplished aimed at improving our Federal transportation system. In particular, MAP-21 established performance measures to ensure the most efficient use of federal transportation funds.  It focuses the program on real world outcomes rather than meaningless bureaucratic checklists, improves accountability by establishing an outcome-driven system to track performance, and directs states and local agencies to consider how they are achieving performance targets when planning for and selecting projects. The performance measures are limited to a select number of specific goals, including safety, infrastructure condition, system reliability, and freight movement. These measures will increase accountability and transparency and help ensure that our citizens are getting the most for their tax dollars.

The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), along with the U.S. Department of Transportation, has been working to implement these performance measures. On April 22, FHWA posted a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) in the Federal Register to propose national performance management measure regulations to assess the performance of the National Highway System, freight movement on the Interstate System, and the Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality Improvement (CMAQ) Program, as required by the MAP-21 and the FAST Act.

Unfortunately, rather than implementing the law passed by Congress, FHWA is proposing to divert attention and resources away from highway and bridge conditions, performance, safety, and attainment of national ambient air quality standards by proposing to adopt a greenhouse gas (GHG) performance measure. In this instance, the Obama administration appears to be diverting FHWA’s time and resources away from achieving the performance goals set forth in law – a law that was enacted with overwhelming bipartisan support from Congress.

FHWA has no authority to establish a GHG measure. The only performance measure related to air quality is directly tied to the implementation of the CMAQ program, and the CMAQ program is limited to programs or projects to help achieve or maintain ozone, carbon monoxide, or particulate matter national ambient air quality standards. GHGs are not part of the CMAQ program and, just as FHWA has no authority to expand the performance measures listed under 23 U.S.C. §150(c), FHWA has no authority to expand the scope of the CMAQ program under 23 U.S.C. §149.

FHWA has already conceded that it does, in fact, lack the authority to implement its GHG proposal. The Federal Register notice fails to set forth any basis for statutory authority for FHWA to establish a GHG performance measure. Recently, FHWA confirmed in a final rule released for Statewide and Nonmetropolitan Transportation Planning that it does not have authority to impose additional performance measures on States and local governments, beyond those specified by Congress. I led five other Senators on my committee in raising these concerns in our comments to the proposed rule (read the letter here).

Should FHWA’s GHG proposal be adopted as a final rule, challenges to this measure will distract FHWA from implementing the measures specified by Congress. One can easily see this same pattern at EPA, which has diverted resources away from its core missions to pursue its so called Clean Power Plan, another GHG regulation, which the Supreme Court has put on hold because it likely goes beyond the authority Congress granted in the Clean Air Act.

The goal of the laws I co-authored is to improve the safety and advance the modernization of our roads and bridges.   FHWA’s proposed GHG regulation would divert the limited time and resources of States and local governments away from this goal to pursue instead the administration’s unlawful and overzealous climate agenda.

In order to effectively improve the performance of our Federal-aid highway program and provide a means to the most efficient investment of Federal transportation funds, FHWA must faithfully implement section 1203 of MAP-21, as enacted by Congress, and forego inclusion of an unauthorized GHG performance measure.

Senator Inhofe’s views are his own and do not necessarily reflect those of the Eno Center for Transportation.

For an opposing view, see this op-ed from Senator Inhofe’s Democratic counterpart, Senator Barbara Boxer (D-CA).

(Ed. Note. 8-22-2016 – After this op-ed was published, a coalition of 23 highway stakeholder groups submitted comments to the Federal Highway Administration on the proposed rule in agreement with Senator Inhofe’s position. Those comments can be read here.)

Share

Related Articles

Electric Vehicle Credits and Alternative Fuels Provisions Included in Senate’s Clean Energy Act

Electric Vehicle Credits and Alternative Fuels Provisions Included in Senate’s Clean Energy Act

On May 26th, the Senate Finance Committee held a markup of the "Clean Energy Act," advancing the legislation with a 14 to 14 vote tie along...

House T&I Examines Private Sector Role in Addressing Climate

House T&I Examines Private Sector Role in Addressing Climate

On March 17, the full House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee held a hearing titled “The Business Case for Climate...

When It Comes To Clean Energy, USPS Delivery Trucks Don't Yet Answer The Mail

When It Comes To Clean Energy, USPS Delivery Trucks Don't Yet Answer The Mail

While the Postal Service moves slowly toward adopting electric vehicles, Robert Puentes says Biden is on the right track in pushing for EVs.

Webinar: Bus Electrification: The Role Agencies Can Play in Workforce Equity

Webinar: Bus Electrification: The Role Agencies Can Play in Workforce Equity

Transit agencies around the country have been exploring ways to transition to zero-emission bus fleets, and that exploration is poised to...

Long Road, Tough Choices Ahead for Biden Car-Charging Pledge

Long Road, Tough Choices Ahead for Biden Car-Charging Pledge

Robert Puentes discusses electric vehicle adoption and infrastructure expansion as a way reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

New Biden Order Creates Federal Climate-Focused Policy Coordination

New Biden Order Creates Federal Climate-Focused Policy Coordination

President Biden signed a new executive order on January 27 adopting new policies and policymaking structure regarding climate change and...

How Could USDOT Organize Around Climate Under Biden?

How Could USDOT Organize Around Climate Under Biden?

President-elect Joe Biden has indicated that climate change will be one of the biggest, if not the absolute biggest, focus of his...

Webinar: Environmental (in)Justice During COVID-19

Webinar: Environmental (in)Justice During COVID-19

In this webinar, we will address the harm inflicted upon minorities, low-income, rural, and tribal populations through disproportionate...

Increased Focus on Environmental Justice in Federal Transportation Policy Proposals

Increased Focus on Environmental Justice in Federal Transportation Policy Proposals

All federal agencies, including the USDOT, have had a mandate to incorporate environmental justice into their missions since 1994. The...

Road to Recovery Webinar: Rebalancing the Load: How Road User Charging Can Influence Traveler Behavior

Road to Recovery Webinar: Rebalancing the Load: How Road User Charging Can Influence Traveler Behavior

Congestion pricing can be a valuable tool for regions to address congestion and meet goals for sustainability and equity. Intelligent...

Op-Ed: Now is The Right Moment to Address Transportation-Related Air Quality Concerns

Op-Ed: Now is The Right Moment to Address Transportation-Related Air Quality Concerns

Vehicle miles traveled have plummeted across the country with many pre-COVID drivers now working from home (see FHWA’s April 2020 Traffic...

Webinar: Congestion Pricing in the United States

Webinar: Congestion Pricing in the United States

This webinar summarizes Eno's latest research report titled Congestion Pricing in the United States: Principles for Developing a Viable...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks