Eno’s Refreshing the Status Quo Investigates New Ways to Distribute Transportation Dollars

Eno’s Refreshing the Status Quo Investigates New Ways to Distribute Transportation Dollars

October 04, 2019  | Paul Lewis

As the expiration of the federal surface transportation programs approaches, we at Eno decided to bust out the spreadsheets. Given that the factors that decide how more than $40 billion in annual highway funding have not been updated since 2009, we were curious as to how much had changed and what we could learn from creating factors that might be more relevant to today’s transportation needs. Our newest paper, Refreshing the Status Quo, was the result.

Formulas have been part of distributing federal transportation dollars since 1916, allocating funding mostly based on needs (for example, lane miles, population, or air quality non-attainment) or cost-to-complete funding for the Interstate Highways. But for the highway programs, the largest of any in transportation, factors based on real-world conditions are now moot. The process was enlightening and provided a few takeaways for Congress and the transportation industry to consider when working on reauthorization.

First, in an era where data is claiming to be the next oil, the transportation sector has dry wells. Most factors used in the analysis were several years old (and incomplete), and other factors that had traditionally been part of funding distribution had not been updated since 2009. Other factors that could have benefited the analysis, such as ways to measure transportation accessibility, congestion, or nonfatal crashes were lacking in quality or did not exist. Any real change to the distribution factors will need to be fair, and fairness requires good data.

Second, using performance-based factors demonstrated the fallacy of modal silos. If a state is going to be rewarded for reducing roadway fatalities, they could build safer roads. Or they could also cut speed limits, invest in transit, or build better bike infrastructure. But eligibility for a highway safety program is typically limited only for highway projects. If the programs are going to move toward a performance-based system of achieving national goals in safety and economic efficiency, which was an objective in both MAP-21 and the FAST Act, a future program might benefit from allowing states and localities flexibility to spend on whatever mode they think best to achieve it.

Finally, political realities mean new funding will be necessary to enable change. In each scenario, many states lost significant amounts of the funding on which they have come to rely. Meanwhile it makes little sense to twist formula factors solely for the purpose of making states happy, rather than targeting them to the needs Congress wants to fund and the performance they want to encourage. Perhaps reintroducing earmarks will overcome some of these challenges, but past experience shows that members of Congress are mostly concerned about how much their state is receiving. That might change if the program gets more direction, states are given more opportunities to compete for funding, and more flexibility to invest in the kinds of infrastructure that makes sense for them.

A presentation of the paper and the eight distribution scenarios can be viewed here. An article summarizing how states currently receive highway formula dollars is here.

The views expressed above are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Eno Center for Transportation. 

Share

Related Articles

Treasury Deposits $118 Billion Bailout in Highway Trust Fund

Treasury Deposits $118 Billion Bailout in Highway Trust Fund

The Treasury Department's official report on Highway Trust Fund finances for December 2021 is now out, and it shows that the $118 billion...

Debt Limit Likely to Be Increased Next Week, Allowing HTF Bailout to Be Processed

Debt Limit Likely to Be Increased Next Week, Allowing HTF Bailout to Be Processed

The latest debt ceiling crisis will be solved by the middle of next week, without having to delay the latest bailout transfer of the...

Wheels of Fortune: A Centennial Institute Recap

Wheels of Fortune: A Centennial Institute Recap

While reforming surface transportation funding and financing is an evergreen topic in federal Washington, major events over the last two...

Congress Still Can't Leave Without Dealing with Debt Limit

Congress Still Can't Leave Without Dealing with Debt Limit

While Congress has now extended the annual appropriations deadline into next February, there is still no clear path in sight for increasing...

Surface Transportation Programs Extended to Dec. 3 While Budget Reconciliation Bill Gets Refined

Surface Transportation Programs Extended to Dec. 3 While Budget Reconciliation Bill Gets Refined

Last night, the U.S. House and Senate have both agreed to another one-month extension of federal surface transportation funding...

FHWA Projects HTF Highway Account Won't Need Bailout Until Summer 2022

FHWA Projects HTF Highway Account Won't Need Bailout Until Summer 2022

The Federal Highway Administration has notified Capitol Hill that the Highway Account of the Highway Trust Fund probably won't need an...

Senate Clears 1-Month HTF Extension for President's Signature

Senate Clears 1-Month HTF Extension for President's Signature

At 1:30 p.m. today, the U.S. Senate held a special session lasting less than five minutes, during which the Senate passed legislation (H.R....

House Passes 30-Day Surface Extension as Infrastructure Bill Shelved Temporarily

House Passes 30-Day Surface Extension as Infrastructure Bill Shelved Temporarily

After a day-long lapse in Highway Trust Fund spending authority and the furlough of some 3,700 U.S. Department of Transportation employees,...

This federal agency could shut down if Congress doesn't pass an infrastructure bill this week

This federal agency could shut down if Congress doesn't pass an infrastructure bill this week

There were five short extensions in 2014 and 2015 before a five-year bill passed, according to a tally maintained by Jeff Davis, a...

House to Debate Infrastructure Bill Monday, with Possible Reconciliation Bill Later in the Week

House to Debate Infrastructure Bill Monday, with Possible Reconciliation Bill Later in the Week

House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer (D-MD) announced to the House this afternoon that "On Monday, September 27, pursuant to the Rule passed...

Deadlines Start Catching Up with Congress Next Week

Deadlines Start Catching Up with Congress Next Week

After a very slow month, Congress will have to making moves next week to pass some key fiscal policy legislation next week, staring down a...

How Long Can the Highway Trust Fund Go Without Another Bailout?

How Long Can the Highway Trust Fund Go Without Another Bailout?

The Federal Highway Administration briefed states last month on new procedures that would be used in the even that the cash balance in the...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks