COVID Stimulus Talks Reach Ignominious End (Finally)

COVID Stimulus Talks Reach Ignominious End (Finally)

October 30, 2020  | Jeff Davis

For the last several weeks, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin have continued to negotiate the parameters of another large COVID relief funding package, in the range of $1.6 trillion to $2.0 trillion, despite ever-increasing signs that the votes would not be there in Congress to pass such a package (at least before the election).

Those talks finally imploded yesterday. In a letter to Mnuchin dated October 29, Pelosi says that Democrats “are still awaiting the Trump Administration’s promised responses on multiple items of critical importance,” including COVID testing, state and local government aid, a plan for nationwide school reopening, the all-important legal liability issue, and other areas.

Pelosi apparently sent the letter to Mnuchin just after midnight, when it was just barely October 29, and released the letter to the press at the same time. This did not sit well with Mnuchin, who then claimedI woke up this morning and read @SpeakerPelosi’s letter to me in the press. Enclosed is my response. Her ALL OR NONE approach is hurting hard-working Americans who need help NOW!” 

Mnuchin’s response letter called Pelosi’s letter a “political stunt” and says “As it relates to State and Local Funding, Schools, Extended Unemployment Benefits, Liability Protection, and OSHA, we have provided reasonable compromise positions. On these major Pillars you have refused to compromise.” (Ed. Note: Idiosyncratic capitalization is sometimes a sign that the principal wrote the letter themselves, without staff.)

Clearly, it was already too late to get a large aid package passed before the November 3 elections, but this does not bode well for getting a relief package enacted in the November-December lame duck session of the current Congress, either. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) seemed to reject the idea of doing a big COVID bill in the lame duck session, telling a radio interviewer this morning that “I think we need to make a careful, calculated decision about what more to do to deal with this coronavirus. We are throwing money at the search for a vaccine, which is a wise thing to do. We probably need to do another package, certainly more modest than the $3 trillion Nancy Pelosi package. I think that will be something we’ll need to do right at the beginning of the year, targeted particularly at small businesses that are struggling and hospitals that are now dealing with a second wave of the coronavirus. And of course, the challenges for education, both K-12 and colleges.”

The big problem in a lame duck session is always what happens if the elections indicate a change of regime to begin in January. Does the current power structure try to cut final deals, or does the side about to take power hit the brakes and start negotiations anew in January from a position of greater strength? And an extra layer of uncertainty surrounds President Trump, who is unpredictable on his best day. If Joe Biden defeats Trump next week, what will that do to his willingness to sign or veto bills that won’t have any tangible effects until after he leaves office?

Share

Related Articles

DOT Revises Rules for Renamed RAISE Multimodal Grants

DOT Revises Rules for Renamed RAISE Multimodal Grants

The multimodal surface transportation grant program first established in early 2009 and named TIGER by the Obama Administration, and later...

Biden Signs $1.9T COVID/Stimulus Bill Into Law

Biden Signs $1.9T COVID/Stimulus Bill Into Law

President Biden signed into law yesterday the latest $1.9 trillion COVID relief and economic stimulus bill (H.R. 1319), now called the...

Reconciliation Bill On Hold Pending Unemployment Insurance Agreement

Reconciliation Bill On Hold Pending Unemployment Insurance Agreement

The only thing more tedious than a Senate vote-a-rama is, apparently, a suspended vote-a-rama. The period of post-debate amendment...

House Democrats Bring Back Appropriations Earmarks, but Transportation Scope Unclear

House Democrats Bring Back Appropriations Earmarks, but Transportation Scope Unclear

The new chairman of the House Appropriations Committee announced on February 26 (in a 5 p.m. Friday afternoon news dump) that the committee...

House to Vote on $1.9 Trillion COVID Stimulus Tonight

House to Vote on $1.9 Trillion COVID Stimulus Tonight

The House of Representatives is expected to vote late tonight on the $1.9 trillion COVID aid and stimulus bill (H.R. 1319) being moved...

House Democrats to Increase Transit Funding in COVID Bill by $461 Million

House Democrats to Increase Transit Funding in COVID Bill by $461 Million

House Democratic leaders are adding $461 million in extra mass transit funding and a $9 million COVID leave fund for FAA employees to the...

House to Consider Budget Reconciliation Bill Next Week

House to Consider Budget Reconciliation Bill Next Week

The House of Representatives is scheduled to consider a budget reconciliation bill next week that provides up to $1.9 trillion in...

House Committees Approve Budget Reconciliation Bill with $57.5 Billion in Transportation Funding

House Committees Approve Budget Reconciliation Bill with $57.5 Billion in Transportation Funding

House committees have completed action on most of the $1.9 trillion in COVID relief spending requested by President Biden this week, with...

How the House Reconciliation Bill's $30 Billion for Transit Will Be Distributed

How the House Reconciliation Bill's $30 Billion for Transit Will Be Distributed

The budget reconciliation legislation approved by the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee this week provides an additional...

Congress Approves Budget Plan to Fast-Track $1.9 Trillion COVID Stimulus

Congress Approves Budget Plan to Fast-Track $1.9 Trillion COVID Stimulus

The House and Senate this week passed budget blueprints designed to fast-track a $1.889 trillion spending bill for COVID-19 relief and...

Democratic Leaders Intend $57.5 Billion for Transportation in New COVID-Stimulus Bill

Democratic Leaders Intend $57.5 Billion for Transportation in New COVID-Stimulus Bill

Plans by Congressional Democratic leaders for new legislation providing $1.9 trillion in COVID-19 aid and economic stimulus call for $57.5...

Democratic Leaders Introduce

Democratic Leaders Introduce "Skinny" Budget Blueprint for COVID Relief and Stimulus

This afternoon, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) jointly announced that they had released...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks