COVID Aid Is Slowing Regular Mass Transit Spending

COVID Aid Is Slowing Regular Mass Transit Spending

November 19, 2021  | Jeff Davis

A look at recent issues of the Monthly Treasury Statement shows that the huge influx of COVID-related aid to mass transit providers has “crowded out” regular federal mass transit spending by about $3 billion since the start of the pandemic, with more spending slowdowns to come.

The three COVID relief bills together provided over $69 billion in emergency aid from the general fund of the Treasury for transit providers. At the same time, the regular mass transit formula grants program (funded out of the Highway Trust Fund) was still going as usual, providing around $10 billion per year, mostly via formula-based aid to transit providers.

The MTS only shows large budget accounts, and as such, it links every general fund FTA account (except Capital Investment Grants” together in an “other” category. This includes the Administrative Expenses, Technical Assistance and Training, and WMATA Grants accounts (which combine to around $300 million per year), the annual post-2018 general fund supplements for mass transit formula grants ($500 million to $700 million per year), slow-spending Hurricane Sandy aid, and all the COVID aid.

Here are the monthly outlays (in millions of dollars) to liquidate obligations for all those accounts – $1.2 billion in pre-COVID calendar year 2019, $16.3 billion in 2020, and $12.1 billion so far in the first ten months of calendar year 2020.

Outlays from Transit “Other” Accounts (Admin, Research & Training, ER, WMATA, GF supplement, COVID Aid)
1st 10 mo
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec 12-mo CY of CY
2019 80 103 75 74 111 69 103 79 94 88 147 141 1,164 876
2020 86 148 133 111 3,339 2,423 2,769 2,031 1,874 1,178 946 1,237 16,275 14,092
2021 1,090 775 883 1,327 1,045 1,033 1,095 1,476 2,416 912 12,052

Now, let’s look at the monthly outlays over the same period from the Transit Formula Grants account (the only Highway Trust Fund account at FTA).

Outlays from Transit Formula Grants account (Highway Trust Fund)
1st 10 mo
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec 12-mo CY of CY
2019 716 941 629 618 744 1,245 885 1,007 1,668 689 834 851 10,827 9,142
2020 843 693 726 874 610 995 966 624 1,227 457 556 841 9,412 8,015
2021 493 668 682 598 564 892 457 647 1,105 441 6,547

Trust Fund outlays for mass transit were $1.4 billion lower in calendar 2020 than in calendar 2019, and for the first ten months of 2021, outlays are another $1.5 billion below the levels of 2020. If 2019 was supposed to be the normal benchmark, 2022 outlays are running $2.6 billion below 2019, with two months to go.

There is still at least $40 billion in COVID aid to transit agencies that has not yet been liquidated via outlays, suggesting that this crowding out, or “substitution effect,” is not a short-term phenomenon.

This raises the question of just how quickly transit agencies will be able to put the 34 percent increase in transit formula apportionments for fiscal 2022 authorized by the bipartisan infrastructure law, set to arrive in two or three months (after the annual DOT appropriations bill is enacted), to use.

Share

Related Articles

COVID Aid Is Slowing Regular Mass Transit Spending

COVID Aid Is Slowing Regular Mass Transit Spending

A look at recent issues of the Monthly Treasury Statement shows that the huge influx of COVID-related aid to mass transit providers has...

The Case for Better Rail Transit Routing to Maximize Public Benefits

The Case for Better Rail Transit Routing to Maximize Public Benefits

This article is focused on aspects of Eno’s latest report: Saving Time and Making Cents: A Blueprint for Building Transit Better. For...

The High Cost of Over-Customized Transit Stations

The High Cost of Over-Customized Transit Stations

Public transit stations are an important part of the communities they serve. Good design can have a positive impact on riders and help...

T&I Hearing Examines Ferry Services and Federal Subsidies

T&I Hearing Examines Ferry Services and Federal Subsidies

On September 28, T&I’s Highways and Transit Subcommittee held a hearing, titled “Examining the Role of Ferries in Improving...

The Case Against Mega Contracts in Mega Transit Projects

The Case Against Mega Contracts in Mega Transit Projects

This article is focused on aspects of Eno’s latest report: Saving Time and Making Cents: A Blueprint for Building Transit Better. For...

T&I Hearing Assesses COVID Funding for Transit

T&I Hearing Assesses COVID Funding for Transit

Yesterday, the full House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee held a hearing titled “Assessing the Federal Government’s...

Derailed Biden infrastructure package could mean loss of $10B for New York Transit

Derailed Biden infrastructure package could mean loss of $10B for New York Transit

“The longer this hangs out there, the greater the chance you’ll have to open it up and perform some surgery on it,” said Jeff Davis,...

Webinar: A New Paradigm for Rail Planning, Funding, & Implementation

Webinar: A New Paradigm for Rail Planning, Funding, & Implementation

In July 2021, the Northeast Corridor Commission released CONNECT NEC 2035 (C35), the most ambitious reinvestment program in the Northeast...

Eno Expands International Transit Construction Cost Analysis with New Projects and Case Studies

Eno Expands International Transit Construction Cost Analysis with New Projects and Case Studies

In July, the Eno Center for Transportation published a major report investigating the high costs and long timelines of rail transit...

Building the Public Sector Workforce Capacity to Build Transit Better

Building the Public Sector Workforce Capacity to Build Transit Better

This article is focused on aspects of Eno’s latest report: Saving Time and Making Cents: A Blueprint for Building Transit Better. For...

Webinar: Trains, Buses, People: An Opinionated Atlas of US and Canadian Transit

Webinar: Trains, Buses, People: An Opinionated Atlas of US and Canadian Transit

Christof Spieler has recently released the second edition of his wildly popular book Trains, Buses, People. Christof’s new book now...

Webinar: A Model for Next-Level Interstate Collaboration with the Port Authority of NY and NJ

Webinar: A Model for Next-Level Interstate Collaboration with the Port Authority of NY and NJ

Created by an Act of Congress in 1921, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey's mission is to oversee the creation of vital...

Be Part of the Conversation
Sign up to receive news, events, publications, and course notifications.
No thanks